Do Dual Physician Families Need Disability and Life Insurance?
We often see questions from physicians married to other physicians (or other high-income professionals) in our online physician communities about whether they really need disability and life insurance. The logic usually goes something like this: "If something happens to me, my spouse makes plenty of money. They could support our family." On paper, that sounds reasonable. And it's true that a second high income gives you a cushion that many single-income households don't have.
But when we dig a little deeper, the plan often has a big hole in it. Your backup plan is a person, and people can get sick, get injured, pass away, or, yes, get divorced. Sometimes something even happens to both of you at the same time. You've both worked far too hard to build your careers to leave your family's financial security dependent on someone else's ability to earn. Below, we'll walk through what dual physician families should think about when it comes to disability and life insurance, and why having two incomes can actually make getting your own coverage easier, not less necessary.
Disclosure/Disclaimer: This page contains information about our sponsors and/or affiliate links, which support us monetarily at no cost to you. These should be viewed as introductions rather than formal recommendations. Our content is for generalized educational purposes. While we try to ensure it is accurate and updated, we cannot guarantee it. Rules/laws can change frequently. We are not formal financial, legal, or tax professionals and do not provide individualized advice specific to your situation. You should consult these as appropriate and/or do your own due diligence before making decisions based on this page. To learn more, visit our disclaimers and disclosures.
Why dual physician couples often skip disability and/or life insurance, and why it’s a problematic argument
We understand the reasoning. You already have two substantial incomes, and you could live off of one income. Insurance is supposed to be for catastrophic situations where you can’t afford the damages - you can. You lived like a resident before - why couldn’t you do it now if you had to? Your insurance plan can be your spouse, so why spend money on premiums instead of diverting that money towards retirement or enjoyment as a family?
The list goes on - you both have policies at work, you’ll hit FIRE in a few years anyways because you’re saving so much money, etc. Some couples simply never got around to it during the chaos of training, early attendinghood, and young kids, and now it’s much more expensive than what you hear others are paying.
Bottom line, it’'s easy to feel like you're already protected or that this is an unnecessary expense.
The problem is that this approach treats your spouse's income as a guarantee. It isn't. It's an assumption, and it's one that's built on the exact same kinds of risks you're trying to avoid by having insurance in the first place.
If you’re already convinced that you need insurance for both but haven’t locked in on policies, our insurance agents directory for doctors contains a list of sponsors who thousands of members of our online physician communities have used. If you aren’t, read on (and even if you are, the article has things to consider as you decide how much of each to get).
What happens if your backup plan can't earn money (or enough money)?
If your plan for a disability or death is "my spouse will cover it," ask yourselves what happens in each of these scenarios.
Something happens to both of you at the same time
Dual physician couples often travel together, commute together, and share the same household risks. A car accident, a natural disaster, or even a contagious illness can affect both spouses at once. If neither of you has coverage, your kids or other dependents could be left with nothing to replace either income.
Your spouse becomes disabled or passes away first
If your spouse is your safety net and something happens to them, you're now the sole earner with no backup plan of your own. If you've also put off buying coverage, you may be older or have developed health conditions by then, which can make new policies more expensive or harder to qualify for.
You get divorced
Nobody likes to think about it, but divorce happens, including among physicians. If your financial plan depended on your spouse's earning power, that plan may no longer exist after a divorce. Having your own policies means your protection stays with you regardless of what happens in your relationship.
Your household is built on two incomes
Many dual physician families have a lifestyle, mortgage, childcare costs, and savings goals that are sized for two incomes. Losing one income can mean much bigger changes than you might expect. A surviving or caregiving spouse may also want or need to cut back on clinical hours to care for children or a disabled partner, which reduces the household's income even further.
You can technically live on one income, but do you want to?
Double clicking on the last point, because it’s a big one. While it may technically be possible to survive on one income, is that what you want for each other?
You have the luxury of protecting each other
While insurance can be a substantial expense, ultimately, you can afford it. Think seriously not just about what you could pull off financially and with lifestyle changes, but what you’d want for each other. If you pass away or can’t earn money, do you want the surviving spouse to have to work harder to support your family? Expenses could go up if you’re disabled or if you pass away - hiring others to help you or to help cover the roles you used to in the family is expensive. Do you want the surviving spouse to have to downgrade your family’s lifestyle if one spouse isn’t around, or would you prefer that the children can stay in the same school and the same house, and take the same vacations?
Family dynamics and spousal relationships can change when one spouse depends on the other financially
This is another very important consideration. While we’d all like to think that we support each other (and may genuinely support each other), taking good care of a spouse in pregnancy or during a rough patch is different than permanent disability. Do you want the spouse that’s not earning to feel like they have to ask the other spouse for money when they want to splurge, or is a strange power dynamic created when it feels like one spouse is supporting the other financially? Also, relationships can go south once this additional tension is introduced - what if this leads to divorce? Is there enough money in the settlement to give you the life that you want?
You’ve both worked too hard not to have your own financial security
The fact is, both of you have worked too hard not to have your own financial security and what you want for your family to depend on somebody else. If you’re used to providing for yourself and having the things that you want, you should be able to have those things even if you’re disabled, without having to ask or depend on somebody else for it. If your vision of what you want to provide to your children is a paid off education, you may want to secure that for them through good life insurance. The list goes on. Ultimately, the cost of life and disability insurance is a small price to pay for the peace of mind.
PSG resource: Our insurance agents directory for doctors contains a list of sponsors who thousands of members of our online physician communities have used.
Disability insurance considerations for doctors married to doctors, and why it’s important for BOTH spouses to have it
Let’s cover some scenarios specific to each type of insurance. For most physicians, your ability to earn an income over the next few decades is your single largest financial asset. Disability insurance protects that asset. And statistically, you're more likely to experience a disability during your working years than to die during them, which is why we often think of disability insurance as the first policy to get right.
Your spouse's income doesn't replace yours
Even if your spouse could technically cover the bills, a long-term disability is expensive in ways people don't always anticipate. There may be medical costs, home modifications, caregiving needs, and lost retirement contributions. Your household could go from saving aggressively to simply getting by, and the plan you built together for retirement, college, and financial independence could be pushed back by years.
Don't rely only on group coverage
Many employers offer group long-term disability insurance, and it's a great starting point. But group policies often have limitations, such as benefit caps that may not fully cover a physician's income, benefits that are taxable if your employer pays the premiums, less physician-friendly definitions of disability, and coverage that usually doesn't come with you if you change jobs. For many physicians, an individual policy can help fill those gaps. Read more about why doctors shouldn’t rely on their disability policy from work.
Look closely at the definition of disability
The definition of disability in your policy matters a lot. A true own-occupation definition generally means you can receive benefits if you can't perform the duties of your specific specialty, even if you could work in another role. For physicians, whose training is highly specialized, this distinction can be a big deal. Also consider riders such as residual or partial disability, future increase options, and cost-of-living adjustments, which can be especially valuable if you expect your income to grow. Read more about the importance of true own occupation disability insurance and about the riders you should have on your disability insurance policy.
Get coverage while you're young and healthy
Disability insurance is medically underwritten, so your premiums and eligibility depend on your age and health when you apply. A new diagnosis, a back injury, a mental health history, or pregnancy can lead to exclusions, higher premiums, or denials. Waiting until "later" can mean paying more for less coverage, or not being able to get it at all.
Get disability insurance for both physician spouses, not just the higher earning one
Let’s say this one again. Insure both spouses. First of all, both of you earn a lot of money and have earned the right to have independent financial security. Second, it’s not only not fair for one spouse to have their income protected just because they’re the higher earning spouse, but expenses for the family could rise if the lower earning spouse (perhaps secondary to working part time, having better hours, or having a more flexible schedule) isn’t able to earn anymore - or if they have significant care needs. Having disability insurance for both of you protects both of you from additional financial earning responsibilities, as well as ensures that if you unfortunately get divorced or something happens to one spouse, the other retains disability insurance protection.
Life insurance considerations for dual physician families
Life insurance is about protecting the people who depend on you. If you have children, a mortgage, or a spouse whose lifestyle and plans assume your income, you likely have a need for coverage, even if your spouse is a physician too.
Think about what your income actually pays for
In a two-income household, each income usually has a job to do. One may cover the mortgage while the other funds retirement accounts, childcare, and college savings. If one income disappears, the surviving spouse may be able to keep the lights on, but likely can't keep every goal on track, or may feel a lot of financial pressure at a team where they and the children are healing and need time to recover. Life insurance can help pay off debt, fund your kids' education, and keep retirement plans intact.
Consider the cost of a single-parent household
If you pass away, your spouse doesn't just lose your income. They may also lose your help with childcare, school pickups, and running the household. Many surviving physician spouses choose to cut back on clinical work, at least for a while, to be more present for their kids. The surviving spouse may also want to move to another city to be closer to family or other help, and may not be able to float a down payment on a new house until things have been settled with the estate and the other house is sold. Life insurance can give them the freedom to make choices without financial pressure.
Check what happens to your debts
Review what would happen to any debts you have, including student loans, a mortgage, or practice loans, if you die. Some loans may be discharged, while others may become the responsibility of your estate or a co-signer. Make sure your coverage accounts for anything your spouse could be left to pay.
Term life insurance is often a good fit
For many physicians, term life insurance provides a large amount of coverage for a relatively low cost, and is designed to last through the years when your family is most financially vulnerable. Permanent policies can have a role in certain situations, but they're more complex and more expensive, so make sure you understand exactly what you're buying and why before choosing one.
Don't forget your beneficiaries and estate plan
Insurance works best alongside an estate plan. Make sure your beneficiary designations are up to date, especially after major life events like marriage, divorce, or having children. If you have minor children, consider how the money would be managed for them, such as through a trust, and who would serve as guardian if something happened to both of you. Also consider that the surviving spouse may get remarried and have financial obligations to another spouse or children, so make sure you feel comfortable with what is definitely in your kids’ name if that scenario were to arise.
Two incomes make coverage easier to afford, not less necessary
Here's the part that often gets overlooked: having two physician incomes doesn't just give you a backup plan. It also makes the cost of protecting yourselves much easier to absorb. A single-income family may have to make real tradeoffs to pay for disability and life insurance. In a dual physician household, those premiums are usually a much smaller percentage of your combined income.
We like to think of it this way: you've both put in years of training, debt, and sacrifice to get where you are. Each of you deserves protection that's in your own name and doesn't depend on someone else. Your insurance shouldn't disappear because of a job change, a divorce, or a tragedy that affects your spouse. Here are a few practical tips for dual physician couples:
Shop for both policies at the same time. Working with an independent agent who can compare multiple companies can help you find the right fit for each of you, and some insurers or associations may offer discounts for buying multiple policies.
Buy coverage that matches each of your incomes. Each spouse's coverage should reflect what their income contributes to the household, not just one person's.
Revisit your coverage regularly. Your needs will change as your income grows, your family changes, and your savings increase.
PSG resource: Our insurance agents directory for doctors contains a list of sponsors who thousands of members of our online physician communities have used.
When could you stop needing coverage?
Insurance doesn’t need to be forever. The goal is to protect your family until you've built enough wealth to protect yourselves. Once your savings and investments could support your family's lifestyle and goals without either income, you may be able to "self-insure" and drop some or all of your coverage. Many physicians reach this point later in their careers, which is one reason why term life insurance and disability policies that run to a specific age can make sense.
The key is that this decision should be based on your actual financial picture, not the assumption that your spouse will always be able to cover you.
Questions to ask yourselves as a couple
Before deciding you don't need coverage, sit down together and talk through these questions:
If one of us couldn't work tomorrow, could we keep our current lifestyle, savings rate, and retirement plans?
If something happened to both of us, who would care for our children, and what money would they have?
How would our family and marriage dynamics change if one spouse is financially dependent on the other?
Would either of us want to cut back on work to care for our kids or a disabled spouse?
What debts would remain, and who would be responsible for them?
Does our group coverage follow us if we change jobs, and is it enough?
Are our beneficiary designations and estate documents up to date?
Do we have enough assets to self-insure yet? If not, when do we expect to?
Conclusion
Being part of a dual physician family is a real financial advantage. But a second high income is not the same thing as insurance. Disability, death, and divorce all happen, and sometimes the unexpected affects both spouses at once. If your only backup plan is your spouse, you're counting on a single point of failure. You’re also counting on relationship dynamics and/or financial pressures not changing.
You've both worked too hard to leave your family's financial security up to chance or to someone else. The good news is that two incomes make it easier to afford your own protection. Get coverage while you're young and healthy, make sure each policy fits each spouse's income and needs, and revisit your plan as your wealth grows. When you reach the point where you can truly self-insure, you can drop coverage on your own terms.
Related resources for physicians
Sign up for our weekly newsletter for alerts about side gig opportunities, upcoming related free webinars, additional educational resources, and more.
Related PSG resources: