Indexed Universal Life Insurance (IUL): What to Know Before You Buy
It used to be that we got lots of posts in our online physician communities about whole life insurance after an insurance salesman approached a doctor and tried to pitch them on the benefits of purchasing this product (which for most people, is not great financial advice, as these products can be more beneficial for the person selling them’s wallet than the person buying it). The word seems to have gotten out that whole life insurance has issues, as we see those questions less these days. However, what we are seeing are more posts about alternative permanent life insurance products. One that comes up often is Indexed Universal Life Insurance (IUL). Below, we’ll cover what Indexed Universal Life insurance is, what to know before purchasing an IUL policy (or even talking to a salesman who is trying to sell you one), why term life insurance is usually better, and when IUL may be appropriate
Disclosure/Disclaimer: Our content is for generalized educational purposes. While we try to ensure it is accurate and updated, we cannot guarantee it. Rules/laws can change frequently. We are not formal financial, legal, or tax professionals and do not provide individualized advice specific to your situation. You should consult these as appropriate and/or do your own due diligence before making decisions based on this page. To learn more, visit our disclaimers and disclosures.

What is Indexed Universal Life (IUL) Insurance?
If you are reading this while you’re just learning about life insurance, we recommend that you read our life insurance primer for physicians and learn the basics. For most physicians, term life insurance is the product you want, not permanent life insurance, so if anybody’s selling you a permanent life insurance product before you even have term life insurance, there’s a greater than not chance that you should be running in the other direction and talking to another insurance agent.
PSG resource:
Life insurance agents for physicians (this list has been used by thousands of our members)
Indexed Universal Life (IUL) insurance policies are a form of permanent life insurance, so it offers not just a death benefit, but also a cash value account that builds value over time from the premiums that are paid into it. In other words, it mixes insurance with investing (which most financial advisors who don’t sell insurance policies warn against!).
The key features of an IUL policy are:
Permanent insurance - as long as you fulfill your contractual requirements to pay the premiums on time and keep the policy funded adequately, this coverage, unlike term policies that may only last for 10-30 years, will last for life.
Potential cash value accumulation, which you can have access to while you hold the policy - the value of your policy can grow over time (but this will depend on how the index does, your fees, and how much you’ve paid in), and if needed, you can take withdrawals or loans against it (subject to policy provisions, available value, interest charges, and tax rules)
Index-linked interest credits - rather than investing the money that you pay towards your premiums, the cash value interest that accrues is based on a formula tied to an index like the S&P 500 or another stock market index
Flexible premiums - unlike term life insurance, which usually has a steady payment from year to year, these policies can allow premiums to vary as long as your overall policy is abiding by the contractual obligations
An IUL policy credits the policy according to the performance of a market index like the S&P. The basic premise is that you pay the premiums, and the insurer - after deducting various charges - will credit the policy based on the selected index strategy. If you pass away while the policy is in force, the insurance will pay your beneficiaries the contractually owed death benefit.
While this may sound great, there are fees, contractual rules, and limitations to the policy which mean that you likely won’t make the same amount of money over time that you would by just investing those premiums, which is where the cries to not mix insurance with investing come from.
Is IUL the same as whole life insurance?
There are several types of permanent life insurance. Each of these carry similar characteristics, but have unique aspects to them. Both IUL and whole life insurance policies are permanent life insurance products which are sold as providing lifetime coverage and building tax-deferred cash value, but there are important distinctions between these products and other permanent life insurance policies. Read details in our dedicated article about the different types of permanent life insurance.
Why do physicians often find the sales pitch for these from insurance agents attractive?
The way that these products are pitched can make them sound like a no brainer. At first glance, IUL appears to speak to several goals that physicians have in terms of tax advantages, wealth accumulation, asset protection, and financial security for their families. It gives you a way to have life insurance protection for life instead of a set period of time, it gives you the ability to make money off of the premiums that’s linked to stock market performance in a safe way since it tends to avoid market losses, and it allows you to access that money at a low cost if needed, lowering the need for personal loans or more expensive means of borrowing.
Common things you may hear in a sales presentation for IUL life insurance
"You can participate in the market without the downside."
"You can use it as your own personal bank."
"You can retire tax-free because of the cash-value by taking loans from the policy.”
"The wealthiest people use this strategy."
"You are a high earner, so you need tax diversification."
"You can fund it aggressively now and let it grow."
So what’s the catch or caveat with IUL plans?
We’ll talk about this in detail below, but fundamentally you have to understand that just because a product offers attractive features doesn’t mean that it’s the most efficient way to achieve each of them. Complexity adds costs and fees that rapidly erode at the value you may be getting out of that money if you did life insurance and investing separately.
The people selling these permanent life insurance plans are incentivized to gloss over this point because they make so much money from these plans - often 5 figure or even 6 figure amounts while you hold these policies. They make a good percentage of the first years premium, as well as recurring incentives every year that you hold the policy. This is why the sales push can feel particularly predatory.
Remember, while doctors are wealthy overall on average, that doesn’t mean the average physician makes as much as the richest people, so the wealthiest people using this strategy may not apply to you. If you don’t have ten to hundreds of million dollars, the tax strategies may be irrelevant. Talk to a financial advisor who doesn’t benefit from selling you insurance plans to get a better assessment.
PSG resource:
So are they never appropriate?
Never say never. These products can be appropriate in certain estate or business planning situations, or when accounting for special personal circumstances. There are certain reasons why complex tax planning incorporates these strategies that are valid. But for the vast majority of physician families just looking to have life insurance to protect their family and loved ones from the financial consequences if something happened to them, term life insurance is generally a much more straightforward - and cost efficient - way to achieve that goal.
a product that offers several financial features is not necessarily the most efficient way to achieve any one of them.
Why isn’t getting returns matched to the S&P index fund perfect? That’s where my money would be anyways, and I can’t lose money here.
It’s important to understand how the insurance index-crediting mechanism works. IUL policies use 3 core concepts - the floor, the cap, and the participation rate.
Floor: This is the minimum interest crediting rate, which is often 0%. It does mean that you can’t get a negative credit for that period, but doesn’t mean that your policy’s cash value can’t decline, because the fees will still be deducted from the value of your policy, and they’re significant.
Cap: There’s a maximum interest rate that will be credited for a given period under each strategy - if that cap is 10%, it doesn’t matter if the market returns 20% that year - you’ll only get 10%.
Participation rate: More complicated, but essentially a percentage of the index’s measured gain is used to calculate the interest credit based on the policy’s formula and other applicable limits.
The details vary a lot, but the TLDR takeaway is that the policy offers a means by which you can get interest, rather than a guarantee of stock-market-like returns without risk.
What do the fees of an IUL look like?
Again, every policy varies, but there are multiple layers of expenses that can affect cash-value growth and the policy's ability to remain in force. If you’re considering one of these, you’re going to want to see a detailed breakdown of every fee being charged and under what condition. Don’t accept vague or general statements as an acceptable answer, because you may be shocked what you see when you look at how substantial the fees are, and how much these fees add up. Without getting into too much detail, examples of fees include:
Cost of insurance: pays for the mortality risk assumed by the insurer if you pass away before you’ve paid more in premiums.
Premium expense charges: this is complicated but know that not every dollar paid in premium contributes to cash value accumulation - it may be a percentage instead
Administrative and policy fees: there are often monthly policy fees, administrative expenses, issue fees, and other contract-specific charges. These can be fixed or vary.
Surrender charges: most policies impose surrender charges, especially during the first decade or so, which means the amount of your cash balance that you get back could be dramatically eroded at if you cancel the policy
Optional riders and additional charges: there’s lots of other riders that can carry charges, including accelerated death benefits, disability-related provisions, or other contractual features
Index-strategy charges and other expenses: the policy may actually apply costs for picking and applying the index strategies depending on options available
That’s a lot, but just know that what you need to be thinking about is how much of every dollar of premium paid actually remains in the policy after charges, and what value you can access if you change my mind or cancel the policy.
Why term life insurance is generally better for most physicians
Term life insurance is generally relatively affordable (especially when compared to other insurance products physicians typically need like disability or malpractice insurance), and gets the job done - it protects those dependent on your income from financial catastrophe or major lifestyle changes if you were to pass away. While it doesn’t build cash value, that’s not the point. If you take the money you save in premiums, and invest it in the stock market without all of the fees mentioned above, you’re likely to come out way ahead in the growth of that money.
PSG resource:
Life insurance agents for physicians (this list has been used by thousands of our members)
Summary of the pros and cons of IUL policies

Pros of IUL life insurance policies
Potential lifetime death-benefit protection - if you have a genuine need for permanent life insurance because of a permanent financial obligation or estate planning need, this can give you it
Tax-deferred cash-value accumulation: generally speaking on a federal level, cash value in these policies grows on a tax-deferred basis (note that the fees may be more than the taxes you’d pay if you invested the money and paid capital gains, though!)
Potentially favorable tax treatment of policy loans if you need to borrow cash against the policy: often, these policies allow you to access the money without immediate income taxation, though loans do accrue interest and reduce the policy value (and potentially the death benefit)
Index-linked interest with a downside floor: can limit downside in a bad stock market year though the cash value may still decline in a down year because of the charges and fees
Flexibility in premiums and death-benefit design: many policies allow adjustments to premium payments and death-benefit structures within contractual limits, which can be. helpful if financial circumstances change, though it may not prevent loss of coverage
Cons of IUL life insurance policies
Illustrations are not guarantees: the illustrations pitched are based on assumptions that may not materialize, which can happen if interest credits are lower than illustrated, charges are higher than assumed, or premiums are insufficient to cover the various costs. Make sure you request alternative projections using lower crediting assumptions to get a sense of the worst case scenario.
The floor does not eliminate losses: As above, the policy can still lose value because of the fees
Long-term funding risk: this isn’t a savings account; the long-term performance depends on the many things above, and a policy that is underfunded or performs worse than expected may require additional premiums later in life. If you can’t or won’t pay them, you may lose the coverage altogether.
Restricted liquidity: The cash value shown in an illustration isn’t always equivalent to cash that can be withdrawn without consequence. Surrender charges, loan provisions, withdrawal rules, and tax consequences can make the policy substantially less liquid than a brokerage account. Early cancellation can be particularly costly.
Opportunity cost of putting the money instead of elsewhere: as discussed above, this money may be better served investing somewhere else or paying down debt
Complexity and dependence on future assumptions: Ultimately, these policies are difficult to evaluate because of the multiple variables. A small difference in annual credited interest, expenses, premium timing, or loan use can produce a substantial difference over several decades.
Conclusion
IULs are complex insurance products that do provide some attractive features, but the decision to purchase one of these products should be accompanied by some scrutiny, and yes, potentially some cynicism. The fact is that the costs and fees often outweigh potential benefits, and many of the benefits touted by insurance salespeople may not apply to your situation. Make sure you understand the commitment you’re signing up for and the opportunity cost of saying yes to these policies, because they’re not easily reversed. In most cases, most financial advisors who don't benefit from selling insurance policies recommend against these policies, and instead recommend buying term life insurance and investing the difference in premiums instead. If you need help with this, one of the insurance agents on our list of insurance brokers for physicians can help you buy term life insurance.
If you do find yourself in a situation where you have to get rid of the policy, some of the things discussed in this article about getting rid of a permanent life insurance policy may be helpful.
Related insurance resources for physicians
Sign up for our weekly newsletter for alerts about side gig opportunities, upcoming related free webinars, additional educational resources, and more.
Related PSG resources:
