top of page

Should I Buy A Rental Property If It Doesn’t Cashflow Well or Is Lower than Recommended?

6 days ago
8 min read

These days, it’s getting harder (and some in our online physician communities would say borderline impossible) to find real estate properties that demonstrate the cashflow that most real estate resources recommend. Many physicians still want to get into real estate because of the many reasons it is attractive from a tax and diversification perspective, or maybe because they believe a property will appreciate. Below, we’ll cover if you should buy a property for these reasons even if they’re not demonstrating good cashflow, or if cashflow is low or nonexistent. 


Note that this article is really geared towards early physicians just dipping their toes into real estate, rather than sophisticated real estate investors who are able to underwrite for real estate strategies that involve relying on appreciation and complicated tax strategies, and who can sustain the additional risks associated with these strategies..


Disclosure/Disclaimer: Our content is for generalized educational purposes.  While we try to ensure it is accurate and updated, we cannot guarantee it. We are not formal financial, legal, or tax professionals and do not provide individualized advice specific to your situation. You should consult these as appropriate and/or do your own due diligence before making decisions based on this page. To learn more, visit our disclaimers and disclosures.


Things to consider when asking yourself, "Should I buy a rental property with little or no cashflow?"


Regardless of what you invest in, you want assets, not liabilities


There are many reasons why real estate is an attractive investment for physicians, including the tax benefits, the potential for appreciation, and the income diversification (including a shot at the all elusive ‘passive income).


That said, it’s really important that you don’t get so caught up in the pull of the promise of real estate investing that you forget that these should be evaluated just like you would evaluate any other investment opportunity.


The most important thing here is that you want to invest in things that are actively creating value as well as stable assets within your portfolio, instead of being potential liabilities. While real estate can certainly be an asset, not every property you purchase automatically qualifies as a good investment. If it’s not generating income that exceeds its operating expenses, debt service, and maintenance and repair costs, you’ll find yourself taking money out of your savings to keep it afloat, making it a liability.


While not every investment property will produce substantial cash flow from day one (for example, if you decide to rehab the property to force appreciation or otherwise add value to it), you should have a well defined plan with factors that you can control for how this property will produce meaningful returns. While appreciation is icing on the cake, it should not be the plan - you can not control this factor.



Don’t count on appreciation of your rental property to make it a worthwhile investment


This point is worth double clicking on, because it’s one of the most common mistakes we see physicians in the community making. There are so many comments about, “Real estate always increases in value,” or “home prices in my area have doubled in the past ‘x’ number of years.” 


Yes, historically, real estate appreciates over time, but that doesn’t mean every property will - or even if it does, that it will appreciate in a way that justifies the opportunity cost of holding that money up instead of having it invested elsewhere. 


Appreciation is influenced by numerous factors (the vast majority of which are beyond your control aside from active improvements you make to the property), including local economic conditions, population growth, interest rates, housing supply, employment opportunities, and broader market trends.


Also consider that if the property is a liability that you need to keep pouring money into, you may have to sell it before that appreciation happens. Or, as many people who invested in the early 2020s are seeing, interest rates can rise and insurance premiums can increase, dramatically altering the amount of profit you’re making or even resulting in net payments out of pocket.


Unlike rental income, appreciation is generally an unrealized gain until you sell or otherwise monetize the property. And even when you do sell, remember that you don’t pocket all the appreciation - there’s still transaction costs, taxes, and other expenses which count against and significantly reduce your actual profit.


A good investment should ideally make financial sense without requiring you to predict what the market will do in the future - i.e. it needs to cashflow.


Rental property appreciation: what you control vs. what is out of your control


Don’t let the tax tail wag the dog - tax benefits shouldn't make a bad investment look good


Those that really want you to buy real estate will tout all the tax benefits of investing in real estate - which granted, are legit, when things go right. 


Especially for physicians who are in high tax brackets, we see in our physician communities that real estate tax benefits can be particularly appealing. It’s just important to not equate tax savings with investment returns. Saving $10,000 in taxes doesn't make a property that loses $20,000 annually a good investment. You've still lost money.


Just like appreciation, tax benefits should be looked at as improving the overall return of an already attractive investment. They should NOT be used to justify purchasing an otherwise poor investment. 


PSG resources:



Diversification is important, but boring diversification is also just fine


Of course, here at Physician Side Gigs, we believe in income diversification and multiple revenue streams. Most physicians have substantial exposure to the stock market through retirement accounts, brokerage accounts, and other investments. Real estate is a natural ‘next’ answer when questions come up in the group about other options. It provides exposure to a different asset class whose ups and downs may not be directly tied to the stock market. While the market fluctuates or when down years prevent you from accessing your investments without selling at a loss, rent can provide stable income. 


Again, though, a bad investment will always be a bad investment, regardless of the asset class. You still need this to be cashflowing.



Don't forget the opportunity cost of not investing the money elsewhere


Let's say you purchase a property that costs you $25,000 as a down payment, and which is actually costing you $500 a month to hold. That’s $31,000 a year that could have been in the market getting you historical rates of return of 6-10% over time. It’s also money that could have been used to pay down high interest debt like your student loans or your mortgage, or money that could be allocated toward another investment or practice buy in.


Over 10 or 15 years, those contributions of non-investment return years could have compounded into a meaningful amount of wealth.


This is why it’s also important to ask not just whether the property might lose money, but also whether it will be better for you in the long run than the alternatives available to you for where you could have put that money.



So, should you buy a real estate investment rental property if it’s not cashflow positive or if it only generates low cash on cash return?


While there are no absolute answers and individual circumstances certainly matter, we’d argue that the answer is usually no for most beginning real estate investors. If you are a sophisticated enough real estate investor who fully understands other real estate strategies and are able to stomach and survive the additional risks of these strategies, there are still arguments to be made for buying low cash flowing assets. This article is really geared towards early physicians just dipping their toes into real estate.



Your cash on cash calculations could get worse than the best case scenario you’re mapping out


If the property isn’t cash flowing well in the first place, it also doesn’t account for surprise expenses, maintenance or repairs, or downward changes in the market.



When might buying a low cash flowing rental property make sense?


There are certainly some situations where it might make sense to sacrifice current cash flow - for example, buying properties in rapidly appreciating or growing markets, properties that could produce great cash flow with a little renovation, or a known reason why rent will increase over time (a big employer moving to the area, for example).


The important thing here is that you should have a clear pro forma with reasonable and tested assumptions, rather than basing this on a gut instinct, FOMO, or other speculative statement.



Checklist for purchasing a rental property with little or no cash flow


Ask yourself these questions:


  • Am I buying this property because it represents a good investment, or because I want to own real estate?

  • Would this investment still make sense for other reasons even if the property never appreciated?

  • Can I comfortably afford the property if vacancies, repairs, or other unexpected expenses arise?

  • Am I accounting for all expenses, including maintenance, capital expenditures, property management, insurance, taxes, and financing costs?

  • What is my expected total return, and how does it compare with alternative investments?


If the investment only makes sense under optimistic assumptions about appreciation, rent growth, or future market conditions, or if the answer is, “I just want to dip my toes into real estate,” that should give you significant pause.



Other properties will come up that do make sense, and you should spend your time learning about how to identify those opportunities instead


The great thing about real estate is that because of the complicated market, there are great deals in every market, regardless of overall market conditions. There are always properties that need to be sold below market value because of death, divorce, financial difficulties, or other reasons. There are always hidden gems that pop up because they’re underpriced or because the owner needs to get rid of the property quickly for some reason. You may see a property that has hidden potential that nobody else does.


But you need a game plan for profitability. Your goal as a real estate investor is to earn money while you’re holding the investment, not to be hoping for a great sale or just happy that you can say you own real estate.



Conclusion


We’re big fans of real estate, and believe that it can be an excellent wealth-building tool for physicians. However, we’re equally emphatic that the reasons touted for buying real estate shouldn't distract you from the fundamentals of investing. The goal isn’t just to own real estate or get a tax write-off - it’s to build wealth. The rest of it is icing on the cake.


Sometimes, the best investment decision is to simply walk away and wait for a better opportunity. There is nothing wrong with sitting on the sidelines, continuing to invest elsewhere, learning more in the interim, and preserving your capital until a property comes along that makes sense.


TLDR: Not buying a bad investment is just as important as buying a good one.



Related real estate resources for physicians 


Sign up for our weekly newsletter for alerts about side gig opportunities, upcoming free webinars (including on real estate investing), new articles and podcast episodes, additional educational resources, and more.


Related PSG resources: 

bottom of page