When or How Often Should Private Practices Renegotiate Their Insurance Contracts?
For almost all medical practices that accept insurance, having strong insurance contracts are arguably one of the largest factors that impact financial performance. And yet, ask physician private practice owners in our online communities for doctors how often they renegotiate their insurance contracts, and most will tell you they’re not sure when the last time they did so was. Below, we’ll cover how often practices should renegotiate their insurance contracts, what factors determine success, and what you can do to improve your chances of success.
Disclosure/Disclaimer: Our content is for generalized educational purposes. While we try to ensure it is accurate and updated, we cannot guarantee it. We are not formal financial, legal, or tax professionals and do not provide individualized advice specific to your situation. You should consult these as appropriate and/or do your own due diligence before making decisions based on this page. To learn more, visit our disclaimers and disclosures.

Why it’s so important to regularly renegotiate your insurance contracts for your private practice
The biggest point here is that you want to be proactive about renegotiating your contracts regularly, rather than waiting for a moment where you’re desperate because of rising overhead or because there’s another financial stressor. The fact is, most private practices don’t think much about their insurance contracts during good times because they're less financially stressed, and that is a huge mistake.
It’s important to regularly assess whether your insurance reimbursement rates are competitive compared to others in your market, whether or not they’re keeping pace with rising operating expenses, and whether they’re adequately compensating you for your time and expertise. If you add expertise, or if market dynamics change, there may be an opportunity for a carveout or renegotiation.
Having a proactive approach to all things related to the financial management of your practice is important, and this is no different. The more you score steady increases, the better you’ll end up in the long run.
When should you renegotiate your insurance contracts?
While you should consider doing this at a regular cadence, there are certain situations where it is particularly important that you consider renegotiating your insurance contracts.
You are approaching a contract renewal date
This is a good time to sit down and evaluate your contracts, and see where there may be opportunities to revisit both lower rates as well as unfavorable terms in your contracts.
It’s important not to wait until the last minute, as this can take a while. Also, many payer agreements contain automatic renewal provisions and specific notice requirements for requesting changes or terminating the agreement, and if you miss these, you may not have the opportunity to do this again for a while - time is money!.
Your reimbursement rate has not increased in many years
As most private practices know, practice overhead is rising across the board. Reimbursement rates are supposed to mirror operating expenses and overhead to some extent, so if your expenses are rising without commensurate increase in insurance reimbursements, it may be time to talk to the the insurance company.
Your practice has grown or expanded the services that you offer
If you’ve added physicians, other clinicians, new specialties, locations, or additional services, your practice may now bring more value to the insurance company's network than it did when the original agreement was signed. The more patients you see over a larger geographic footprint and the more services you offer, the more they need you. These are things that should increase your practice’s negotiating position.
Your practice brings significant value to the network
There are several things that increase leverage, and one of them is if your practice has strong patient access, a reputation of high quality outcomes, and good patient satisfaction. This can reduce unnecessary emergency department visits and hospitalizations
Your current reimbursement rates are significantly below market benchmarks.
Compare your reimbursement rates across insurance companies and, where reliable data is available, against comparable practices in your specialty and geographic area.
If one payer consistently reimburses significantly less than others for the same services, it may be time to request a rate adjustment.
PSG Resource:
Jiro Health: Jiro is a group sponsor and a Practice Intelligence platform built by and for clinicians. Using real-world data tied to each clinician’s NPI, Jiro surfaces clinical, operational, and financial signals that don’t exist in the EHR. Things like opportunities to capture new referrals, how your insurance contracts compare with others, and payment denial patterns. Benchmarked against peers and updated continuously. Delivered without new workflows or added burden. Free to use. No setup required. Jiro is HIPAA compliant, SOC 2 certified, and CME accredited. Get started with our partnership link.
What does it take for a renegotiation of your insurance contracts to be successful?
Of course, just because you ask for a better reimbursement rate doesn’t mean that it will be successful. You’ll usually have to justify why your practice deserves the better rate, and that typically means supplying supporting data and advocating for the worth that your practice has for the insurance company’s network. Here are some tips based on what our physician community has mentioned in the past: Credentialing and Contracting With Insurance Companies and Payors: Tips and Tricks.
Gather your numbers before you reach out to the insurance company
You’ll first want to ensure that you actually know what you’re currently being paid by all payers. As we unfortunately are all painfully aware of, with insurance, this is a harder task than it should be with constantly changing rules and procedures.
You’ll want to understand your reimbursement not just by payer, but by clinician, by CPT code, and by service line. Know which services generate the most revenue and which ones have particularly unfavorable reimbursement rates.
Don’t just look at the billed charges or the percentage of Medicare reimbursement that you are paid, but also at:
Allowed amounts
Denial rates
Payment delays
Underpayments
Administrative costs associated with each payer
This will help you in multiple ways, not just in preparation for negotiation. You may be surprised at what you find. You may find that you no longer want to be in network with a particular payer, or at what number you’d be willing to walk away. The more specific you can be when you’re engaging with the insurance company, the more likely they will be to believe you when you say you won’t do it for ‘x’ rate, and the stronger your negotiating power.
Understand the various levers that give you leverage in a negotiation with an insurance company
Not every medical practice has the same negotiating power, and not every private practice has the same value to each payer. Things that your leverage tends to depend upon include:
Your specialty
Your geographic location and patient catchment
Patient volume
Number of other participating providers within your region
Availability of competing providers
The insurance company’s need for your services
Generally speaking, a specialty practice that serves a large patient population in an area with limited availability of other doctors in that specialty is going to be in a stronger negotiating position than a practice in a highly saturated market.
You’ll also want to see if having you in network provides them with any strategic advantages as they negotiate with other practices or hospital systems in the area. The insurance company is strategizing on multiple levels when they decide what to pay you. If having you in network allows them to walk away from another deal where somebody is negotiation hard with them, they may want to keep you happy so they have you as an option for their patients. A classic example of this mentioned by several of our members is when there’s a hospital system in a more remote area that has primary care services, and relatively few additional primary care practices in the area. In order for the insurance company to be able to negotiate with the hospital, they need to be able to say they have other options. These are cases where even small private practices can hold a lot of leverage.
Determine why your practice is valuable to the particular insurance company
The degree to which the insurance company takes your request seriously is going to correlate highly with how much they want you to be in network. In this situation, it’s not just about if a lot of their enrolled patients see you (though that definitely matters). Things you’ll want to tell them:
Number of their members that your practice serves
How many patients you see total
What geographic catchment area your patients come from
Appointment availability
Breadth of specialty services
Special services your practice provides that others around you may not (you want to show them how hard it will be to replace you)
Quality measures and patient satisfaction scores
Use the data that you have to support your request for rate increases, and choose which rate increases you ask for intentionally
Making a rate increase request without data to back it up is unlikely to be successful. You should develop a specific proposal that’s supported by your current reimbursement data, comparable market benchmarks, changes in operating expenses, and the financial impact of existing rates.
The strategy here is important. If you just ask for better rates across the board, they’re unlikely to agree. You should regularly target key reimbursement rates that truly matter for your practice at that moment, prioritizing specific CPT codes or services where reimbursement is particularly bad or where you know you have a really good case for an increase.
Recognize that you may end up negotiating more than just insurance rates, as other things also have value that will improve your bottom line financial success
Although the reimbursement rate has a lot of value and is usually going to be the main thing you’re pushing for, a savvy practice manager or partner will also consider negotiating things that are indirectly costing the practice money or otherwise diverting resources from the things that make them money.
Here’s some specific things you could consider asking for, depending on your data:
More favorable reimbursement rates for high-volume CPT codes
Annual reimbursement increases or inflation adjustments
Shorter payment turnaround times
Clearer claims submission and appeal requirements
More favorable prior authorization requirements
Improved timely filing and claim reconsideration provisions
More reasonable medical record request requirements
Clearer termination and contract amendment provisions
Additional important pearls and tips from physician colleagues about renegotiating insurance contracts
You don’t necessarily have to wait until your contract expires
Some payers will actually consider midterm amendments or rate adjustments if the case is compelling, so don’t assume you are locked into your existing reimbursement rates until the contract reaches its renewal date. If there’s something that would significantly impact your practice’s finances over the term, and if you already have compelling data to support an increase, consider reaching out. Your leverage will be in how much you can make the case for it to be a good idea for them to change things for a strategic reason on your behalf as well, or, if you’re able to, a statement that you’ll be walking away at the end of the contract period if a condition isn’t met. Understand that you have to mean it when you say you might walk away, because insurance companies do let people walk away, particularly if they know they’ve got somebody waiting in the wings.
Start earlier than you think that you should need to
Perhaps not surprisingly, when you’re dealing with insurance companies, things often take longer than you think they should. Payer negotiations can (and often do) take several months. Begin reviewing your agreements and strategizing about your asks six to twelve months before a renewal date, especially if it’s a key payer for your practice. Also keep track of contractual obligations to provide notice or auto-renewal dates when deciding your timeline.
Prioritize your most important payer contracts and the ones you’re most likely to win
Depending on how quickly you were added to the network initially, your timelines for each insurance company renewal are likely different. That said, you may find yourself negotiating simultaneously, and its important to give your energy to the contracts that matter the most for the financial success of your practice. If you have over 1000 patients with one payer, and only a hundred or so from the other, prioritize the negotiation with the payer that represents the larger portion of your revenue.
Additionally, if you know you have a high chance at success with a particular renegotiation because the rates you currently have are glaringly below market or because they haven’t readjusted their rates in several years, these are low hanging fruits worth targeting.
Know when to walk away
Sometimes despite your best efforts, the insurance company will not budge in a way that moves the needle. While this doesn’t mean you should automatically terminate the contract, it should trigger a deeper analysis of the opportunity cost of continuing to be in network, and the financial implications of continuing the relationship.
Consider the percentage of your revenue attributable to that payer, patient volume, potential patient attrition, out-of-network options, and whether those patients could be replaced with patients from more financially favorable contracts. If you’re a busy practice that often has a waitlist before patients can be seen, remember that the time you spend seeing this company’s patients is time that could be spent seeing patients from another payer.
Another important point - before you terminate an agreement, you’ll want to review the notice requirements, continuity-of-care obligations, patient communication requirements, and applicable state and federal regulations.
Always review the entire contract, not just the fee schedule
The fine print can really matter, even if you’re given a better reimbursement rate. Things that physicians in our communities have regretted signing during renegotiations include automatic renewals, unilateral amendment rights, incorporated payer policies, termination provisions, audit rights, payment recoupments, and dispute resolution procedures. Having an experienced healthcare attorney used to working with physician practices on deck to review proposed amendments is important.
PSG Resource:
Once signed, verify that the changes actually take effect
Several of our members have reported that getting the insurance company to agree to the changes is only the first half. You may have to stay on top of the incoming payments to ensure they actually take effect. Once the amendment has been signed, confirm that the new fee schedule has been loaded correctly into the payer’s system claims system. Also track your own payments and review if the claims that are processed after the agreed upon effective date are reflecting the changes you negotiated. Follow up promptly on any discrepancies.

Next steps
We know this is a lot, so we recommend that your practice first creates and maintains resources to keep track of and prioritize which insurance contracts deserve attention at any given time. We have a dedicated resource with much more detailed checklists, but start with basic things like this.
A Payer Contract Priority Worksheet
Insurance payer Annual collections Last rate increase Priority
Payer 1 $________ __________ High / Medium / Low
Payer 2 $________ __________ High / Medium / Low
Payer 3 $________ __________ High / Medium / Low
Payer 4 $________ __________ High / Medium / Low
Negotiation Goals & Action Plan (done per payer)
Insurance company: __________________________
Contract renewal date: _______________________
Date of last fee schedule increase: ____________
Top three areas requiring improvement:
Requested reimbursement increase: ___________
Additional contractual changes requested:
Person responsible for negotiations: __________
Target date to initiate negotiations: ___________
Follow-up date: _____________________________
Conclusion
The biggest thing that influences your practice’s financial health is how much money is coming in through the claims that you submit. Even small changes can make a huge difference when annualized. Insurance contract renegotiation should be a routine part of your practice management to-do lists, as you’re leaving a lot of money on the table if you just wait for the insurance company to release updates. You’ll want to approach these renegotiations strategically, prioritizing the things that have the most impact or getting the low hanging fruit. The most successful negotiations result from presenting data or making the case for why your practice specifically adds value to the insurance company’s strategy.
PSG Resource:
Jiro Health: Jiro is a group sponsor and a Practice Intelligence platform built by and for clinicians. Using real-world data tied to each clinician’s NPI, Jiro surfaces clinical, operational, and financial signals that don’t exist in the EHR. Things like opportunities to capture new referrals, how your insurance contracts compare with others, and payment denial patterns. Benchmarked against peers and updated continuously. Delivered without new workflows or added burden. Free to use. No setup required. Jiro is HIPAA compliant, SOC 2 certified, and CME accredited. Get started with our partnership link.
Related private practice resources for physicians
Sign up for our weekly newsletter for alerts about side gig opportunities, upcoming free webinars, new articles and podcast episodes, additional educational resources, and more.
Related PSG resources:
